MINUTES
September 15, 1999 SACIA / Stamford
1. Chairman Chabot called the meeting to order at 7:30 p.m. Minutes of the
June meeting were approved.
OLD BUSINESS
2. Stephanie Harwood reported that the unofficial opening of the North End
Access to Grand Central Terminal had occurred in August without fanfare, and
that commuters are making growing use of this project, which provides greatly
improved terminal access for those working at or going to locations north of
the terminal. Except for some minor flooding during the disruptive August 26
storm, all aspects of the access seem to be working well, she said.
Gene Colonese noted that the improvement, while as yet used by only about 20
percent of riders, is creating better distribution of passenger loads, with
less front end crowding and fewer complaints about inadequate seating on
trains (invariably as rear coaches travel with scores of open seats).
Joe McGee raised the issue of proposed Long Island Railroad access to
GCT, noting growing sentiment that any implementation of this plan should
also be broadened to give New Haven Division riders service into Penn Station
via existing Amtrak trackage. Council members agreed with Chairman Chabot’s
contention that Connecticut has no representation in this issue, and that
the plan to give LIRR access to Grand Central appears to be "a done deal."
He noted that hearings to date have been under-publicized and thus poorly
attended, giving proponents the grounds for alleging that there is no
opposition to the plan.
The spokesperson for the concept has been invited to meet with the
Council, but has used schedule conflicts as her explanation for being unable
to do so. It was suggested that she be asked to attend the October meeting,
scheduled to be held in New Haven.
3. Jack Reidy stated that the Stamford Station expansion is proceeding on or
ahead of schedule, except for a delay which will occur due to the erection of
a second pedestrian bridge to the garage (this the result of some delay in
finalizing the garage construction plans).
4. Inoperative escalators and other evidence of shoddy station maintenance
on the part of the City of Stamford were again a meeting topic.
Vice-Chairman Cameron stressed that the station’s condition clearly gives
visitors to Stamford and those with business at the new Swiss Bank an
unfavorable impression of the city. Mr. Chabot said that his conversations
with both the Stamford Mayor Dan Malloy and Herb Cohn, the station’s
supervisor, suggest that they are largely inattentive to problems such as the
escalators. Mr. Cameron noted that Stamford is happy to scoff up parking
garage profits, but then wants CDOT to pay as a capital expense the cost of
escalator repair and renovation.
5. Harry Harris provided an update on the status of CDOT’s contract with
the Metropolitan Transportation Authority for Metro North’s operations. CDOT
wants to work within terms of the contract, he said, but a system exists by
which it must notify MTA/MN by mid-August of the prior fiscal year of
concerns and impending problems CDOT has in continuing to function under the
contract. It has such problems with the Year 2000 contract, he explained,
and these add up to a $7 million deficit, with the option of a fare increase
to cover the deficit unavailable due to a 1999 Legislature resolution. The
deficit does not cover M2 overhaul plans or other administrative needs, he
added.
6. Mr. Harris and Jack Reidy provided an update on the status of the free
com-muter parking lot in Bridgeport, which is being turned over to the city.
A new lot with space for 450 cars is being established east of the station,
using fencing and lighting from the original lot, which will be the site of
an ice hockey facility. The City of Bridgeport will build a multi-level
garage serving both the hockey facility and the Bluefish stadium, and
offering free commuter parking as well.
7. Negotiations for adding a third Fairfield station are continuing, Mr.
Harris explained. The former UPS building site, under consideration, has
been found to have access problems, he added, which would require either a
tunnel through an area with potential water level problems or a widening of
the Black Rock Turn-pike bridge over the railroad. He does not expect
further progress by the time of the next Council meeting.
OTHER OLD BUSINESS. Mr. Chabot asked what is being done about the
construction site adjacent to the re-opened New Canaan station. Previously a parking
lot, this area has not been cleared to permit its renewed use, he said.
Jerry Carney reported that the area has now been re-paved, and will again
become a metered lot in the near future.
NEW BUSINESS
1. Mr. Cameron presented a dossier of website complaints about air
conditioning problems during the July heat wave. He said such complaints
were more extensive than in recent years, and – conceding that the status of
M2 coaches may have caused them to contribute to many failures -- wondered
whether there had been a cutback in maintenance or repair efforts.
Metro North spokespeople offered these explanations: (1) this was the
hottest July on record, but air conditioning complaints dropped sharply
during the far cooler August, (2) the air conditioning systems are not
designed to bring temperatures down into the 70’s, but merely to make them
comfortable, (3) a sampling of records showed that in only 3 percent of all
coaches were air conditioning shortcomings detected, (4) the new North End
Access tunnels do adversely affect air circulation in the terminal somewhat,
and this makes cars heat up more while they are in the terminal, and (5) M2
units did contribute disproportionately to this summer’s numbers.
To members’ questions (and an issue raised by State Senator William
Nickerson), Metro North spokespeople said that they are working to find ways
to bring down summer temperatures in the terminal access areas.
2. Gene Colonese said the Metro North schedule for the New Haven Division
will contain few changes (none in rush hours trains) when released in
October.
3. With meetings slated to be held on the third Wednesday of each month, Mr.
Chabot listed the meeting schedule for the balance of the 1999-2000:
DATE LOCATION
Wed. September 15th 1999 SACIA, 1 Landmark Sq., Stamford
Wed. October 20th 1999 CDOT, Railroad Station, New Haven
Wed. November 17th 1999 Railroad Station, Danbury
Wed. December 15th 1999 SACIA, 1 Landmark Sq., Stamford
Wed. January 19th 2000 CDOT, Railroad Station, New Haven
Wed. February 16th 2000 Railroad Station, Bridgeport
Wed. March 15th 2000 SACIA, 1 Landmark Sq., Stamford
Wed. April 19th 2000 CDOT, Railroad Station, New Haven
Wed. May 17th 2000 Railroad Station, Westport
Wed. June 21st 2000 SACIA, 1 Landmark Sq., Stamford
4. Mr. Cameron cited prolonged delays and instances of passengers stranded
on trains in connection with the August 26 thunderstorm and cloudburst.
George Walker said the sudden volume of water and apparent blockages in the
city water drainage systems south of the Melrose station precipitated the
crisis. Direct current electric systems in coaches’ undercarriages make them
inoperative in water. Drainage was slow following the storm, he explained,
and necessitated both sending some trains back to their points of
origination and backing one train to Melrose for unloading. His associate,
George Okvat, noted that Metro North had recorded 11 complaints tracing to
the storm, but also had received 12 commendations for crews’ conduct and its
services under duress. In the wake of this episode, Mr. Walker detailed Metro
North’s plans for the approaching Hurricane Floyd, including the necessity of suspending
service if winds exceeded 50 miles per hour.
5. Dennis Bloom and his wife, Barbara, with their son, attended the meeting
to ask that fencing be placed along the Danbury branch line in the vicinity of a
Bethel youth center. Two weeks before, their 14-year-old son had been killed
by a train while going to or from a function at the youth center. Mr. Bloom
presented photos of the site and the path used by youngsters in reaching the
facility.
Mr. Bloom was upset that someone at Metro North had hung up on him when he
attempted to present his request for the fence to Metro North by phone. In
the wake of his tragedy, he said, no one at Metro North had contacted him;
nor had anyone, except for the shaken locomotive operator, voiced
condolences over the tragedy.
Mr. Harris and Mr. Reidy noted that trackside fencing is the responsibility
of CDOT, and that it cannot be erected everywhere it is requested. They
cited the state’s investment in the Operation Lifesaver program to educate
adults and children about the dangers inherent in crossing or walking along
tracks.
6. Mr. Harris reviewed the projected delay in the start of high-speed
northeast corridor service due to excessive wheel wear on Acela (sm) coaches.
Tests of the newly installed catenary with current Amtrak equipment will
begin in October, and high-speed travel via that same equipment will begin in
November, he said. CDOT is meeting with Amtrak, he added, to assure that the
service will not interfere with Metro North service or facilities.
OTHER NEW BUSINESS. A public hearing on design of the new State Street
station in New Haven will be held in January, Mr. Harris reported. In reply to
an inquiry by Josh Geballe regarding the possible expansion of Shore Line
East service to weekends, Mr. Harris stressed that deficits from the
operations preclude any expansion. He indicated no expansion of Shore Line
East service will be possible until the Q Bridge renovation is completed, but
that Shore Line East delays associated with the electrification of the line
are over. Mr. Harris noted that a public hearing on the LIRR’s access to
Grand Central Terminal will be held Thursday, October 7. Jeffrey Maron, a
Stamford commuter, suggested that the electronic monitor at the head of the
eastbound escalator in Stamford Station would better serve riders if its
typeface was enlarged. Squinting commuters cause a backup on the escalator,
Mr. Maron said. It was also noted that the underground train indicators in
the New Haven station now operate properly.
Respectfully submitted,
Edward H. Zimmerman
Secretary
In Attendance
Rodney Chabot, Chairman
Jim Cameron, Vice-Chairman
Stephanie Harwood, Council Member
Joe McGee, SACIA and Council Member
Edward Zimmerman, Secretary
Jim Mohs, Council Member
Harry P. Harris, CDOT
Josh Geballe, Council Member
Jack Reidy, CDOT
Carl Leaman, Council Member
George F. Walker, VP, Op's MN
Ben Thompson, Council Member
Jerry Carney, Station concessions
George Okvat, Metro North
Jerry Maron, Stamford commuter
Moe Kiniry, Chief Transportation Officer, MN
Tom McFeely, The Advocate
Scott J. Ab, WICC News, Bridgeport
Eugene Colonese, Metro North
Dennis Bloom, Sandy Hook, CT
Antonio Sorbin, CDOT
Barbara Bloom, Sandy Hook, CT